Ala-Maududi
(33:33) And stay in your homes[48] and do not go about displaying your allurements asin the former Time of Ignorance.[49] Establish Prayer, give Zakah, and obey Allah andHis Messenger. Allah only wishes to remove uncleanness from you, O members of the (Prophet’s)household, and to purify you completely.[50]
48. The word qarna in the original is derived from qarar according to some lexicographers andfrom waqar according to others. In the first sense, it will mean: “settle down, stick firmly”and in the second sense: “live peacefully, sit with dignity.” In both the cases the verse meansto impress that the woman’s real sphere of activity is her home; she should carry out herfunctions within that sphere peacefully, and she should come out of the house only in case of agenuine need. This meaning is clear from the words of the verse itself and the Prophet’s (peacebe upon him) Ahadith also impress it even more forcefully. Hafiz Abu Bakr Bazzar has related onthe authority of Anas that the women made a submission to the Prophet (peace be upon him),saying: “All kinds of virtues have been secured by the men: they fight and accomplish greatdeeds in the way of Allah. What should we do that we may also get a reward equal to that of thewarriors?” The Prophet (peace be upon him) replied: “The one who sits in her house from amongyou; will attain the reward of the warriors.” What he meant was: The warrior can fightconfidently and with full peace of the mind in the way of Allah only when he is sure that all iswell at home. His wife is there to look after the house and the children, and there is no causefor him to worry that she will betray him in his absence. The woman who will provide him thissatisfaction and peace of the mind will be an equal partner with him in his fighting though shewill be sitting back at home. According to another tradition that Bazzar and Tirmidhi haverelated on the authority of Abdullah bin Masud, the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “The womanmust remain veiled and concealed. When she comes out of her house, Satan stares at her. And sheis closer to Allah’s mercy when she is inside her house.” See (Surah An-Nur, ayat 31) note 49.
In the presence of such a clear and express command of the Quran, it is not at all permissiblethat the Muslim women should seek membership of the councils and parliaments; that they shouldrun after social activities outside the house; that they should work side by side with men inthe government offices, should get education along with boys in the colleges, serve as nurses inthe male wards of hospitals, should be employed as hostesses in the airplanes and rail cars, andshould be sent abroad for education and training. The greatest argument that is given in supportof the permissibility of the women’s outdoor activities is that Aishah (may Allah be pleasedwith her) had taken part in the battle of the Jamul. But the people who present this argumentperhaps do not know what was Aishah’s own opinion in this regard. Abdullah bin Ahmad bin Hanbalhas related in his Zawa id az-Zuhd and Ibn Mundhir, Ibn Abi Shaibah and Ibn Saad in their ownbooks the tradition from Masruq, saying that when Aishah during her recitation of the Quranwould reach this verse (wa qarna fi buyut-i kunna), she would start crying involuntarily; somuch so that her head-wrapper would become wet, for this reminded her of the error that she hadcommitted in the battle of the Jamul.
49. In this verse two important words have been used, which must be understood for the properunderstanding of its intention. They are tabarruj and jahiliyyat al-ula.
The word tabarruj in Arabic means to become manifest and appear openly before others. The Arabsuse the word baraj for every conspicuous and elevated object. A burj (tower) is so calledbecause of its prominence and elevation. A sailingboat is called barijah, because its sailsbecome visible from a distance. The word tabarruj when used in respect of a woman will havethree meanings: (1) that she should show the charms of her face and body before the people. (2)That she should display the adornments of her dress and ornaments before others. (3) That sheshould make herself conspicuous by her gait and figure and coquetry. The same explanation ofthis word has been given by the leading lexicographers and commentators. Mujahid, Qatadah andIbn Abi Nujaih say: Tabarruj means to walk in a vain, alluring and coquettish manner. Muqatilsays: It means a woman’s displaying of her necklaces, ear-rings and bosom. Al-Mubarrad says:That a woman should reveal her adornments which she should conceal. Abu Ubaidah comments: Thisthat a woman should make herself conspicuous by display of her body and dress to attract theattention of men.
The word jahiliyyat has been used at three other places in the Quran besides this, in (Surah Aal-Imran, Ayat 154), whereabout those who shirk fighting in the way of Allah, it has been said: “They began to cherishabout Allah thoughts of Ignorance Uahiljyyat, which were void of the truth. And in (Surah Al-Maidah, Ayat 50), where aboutthose who want to be judged by their own law instead of the law of Allah, it has been said: “Dothey desire to be judged by the laws of ignorance (Jahiliyyat)?” and in (Surah Al-Fath, Ayat 26), where theprejudice of the people of Makkah due to which they did not permit the Muslims to perform Umrah,has been called as “the haughty spirit of paganism (jahiliyyat). According to a Hadith once Abuad-Darda in the heat of a quarrel abused another person in respect of his mother. When theProphet (peace be upon him) heard of it, he remarked: You still have jahiliyyat in you.According to another Hadith the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: Three things show jahiliyyat:to taunt the lineage of another person, to take omens from the movement of the stars, and tomourn over the dead. All these customs show that jahiliyyat in the Islamic terminology is everysuch conduct which goes against Islamic culture and civilization and Islamic morality andetiquette and Islamic way of thinking and behavior. Thus, jahiliyyat al-ula would mean all thoseevils in which the Arabs of the pre-Islamic days and the people of the entire world wereinvolved.
This explanation makes it abundantly clear that what Allah forbids women is to move out of theirhouses showing off their physical charms and beauty. He instructs them to stay in their housesbecause their real sphere of activity is their home and not the world outside. However, if theyhave to move out of the house for an outdoor duty, they should not move out as the women used todo in the pre-Islamic days of ignorance. For it does not behoove the women of a Muslim societyto walk out fully embellished to make their face and figure conspicuous by adornments andtightfitting or transparent dresses, and to walk coquettishly. These are the ways of ignorancewhich Islam does not approve. Now everybody can see for himself whether the culture which isbeing made popular in our country is the culture of Islam, according to the Quran, or theculture of ignorance.
50. The context in which this verse occurs makes it manifest that the word ahl al-bait (people ofthe house) here implies the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him), because the address beginswith: “O wives of the Prophet,” and they are the addressees in the whole discourse preceding itas well as following it. Moreover, the word ahl al-bait in Arabic is used precisely in the sensein which the word “household” is used in English, which includes both a man’s wife and children.No one would exclude the wife from the “household.” The Quran itself has used this word at twoother places besides this, and at both the wife is included in its sense, rather as the mostimportant member of the family. In Surah Hud, when the angels give the Prophet Abraham (peace beupon him) the good news of the birth of a son, his wife exclaims: “Shall I bear a child now whenI have grown too old, and this husband of mine has also become old?” The angels say: “What! Areyou surprised at Allah’s decree, O people of Abraham’s household? Allah’s mercy and blessingsare upon you.” In Surah Al-Qasas, when the Prophet Moses (peace be upon him) reaches thePharaoh’s house as a suckling, and the Pharaoh’s wife is in search of a suitable nurse for thechild, the Prophet Moses’ (peace be upon him) sister says, “Shall I tell you of a householdwhose people will bring him up for you and look after him well?” Thus, the Arabic idiom and theusage of the Quran and the context of this verse, all point clearly to the fact that theProphet’s (peace be upon him) wives as well as his children are included in his ahl albait;rather the more correct thing is that the verse is actually addressed to the wives and thechildren become included in the household only because of the sense of the word. That is whyaccording to lbn Abbas and Urwah bin Zubair and Ikrimah, the word ahl al-bait in this verseimplies the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him).
But if somebody says that the word ahl al-bait has been used only for the wives and none else canbe included in it, it will also be wrong. Not only this that the word “household” includes allthe members of a man’s family, but the Prophet (peace be upon him) has himself explained thatthis includes even himself. According to Ibn Abi Hatim, once when Aishah was asked about Ali,she said, “Do you ask me about the person who was among the most loved ones of the Prophet andwhose wife was the Prophet’s (peace be upon him) daughter and most beloved to him?” Then sherelated the event when the Prophet (peace be upon him) had called Ali and Fatimah and Hasan andHusain (may Allah be pleased with them all) and covered them all with a sheet of cloth andprayed: “O Allah, these are my household, remove uncleanness from them and make them pure.”Aishah says, “I said: I also am included among your household (i.e. I may also be covered underthe sheet and prayed for).” Thereupon the Prophet replied: “You stay out: you, of course, arealready included.” A great many Ahadith bearing on this subject have been related bytraditionalists like Muslim, Tirmidhi, Ahmad, Ibn Jarir, Hakim, Baihaqi, etc. on the authorityof Abu Said Khudri, Aishah, Anas, Umm Salamah, Wathilah bin Aqsa and some other companions,which show that the Prophet (peace be upon him) declared Ali and Fatimah and their two sons ashis ahl al-bait. Therefore, the view of those who exclude them from the ahl al-bait is notcorrect.
Similarly the view of those people also is not correct, who, on the basis of the above citedAhadith, regard the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him) as excluded from his ahl al-bait.In the first place, anything which has been clearly stated in the Quran cannot be contradictedon the basis of a Hadith. Secondly, these Ahadith also do not have the meaning that is put onthem. As related in some traditions that the Prophet (peace be upon him) did not cover Aishahand Umm Salamah under the sheet of cloth which he put on the four members of his family, doesnot mean that he had excluded those ladies from his “household.” But it means that the wiveswere already included in ahl al-bait, because the Quran, in fact, had addressed them as ahlalbait. The Prophet (peace be upon him), however, thought that the apparent words of the Quranmight cause somebody the misunderstanding about these members that they were excluded from theahl al-bait. Therefore, he felt the need for clarification in their case and not in the case ofhis wives.
A section of the people have not only misconstrued this verse to the extent that they have madethe word ahl al-bait exclusively applicable to Ali and Fatimah and their children to theexclusion of the wives, but have gone even further and concluded wrongly from its words “Allahonly intends to remove uncleanliness from you and purify you completely”, that Ali and Fatimahand their children are infallible like the Prophets of Allah. They say that “uncleanliness”implies error and sin, and, as Allah says, these ahl al-bait have been purified of this, whereasthe words of the verse do not say that uncleanliness has been removed from them and they havebeen purified. But the words are to the effect: “Allah intends to remove uncleanliness from youand purify you completely.” The context also does not tell that the object here is to mentionthe virtues and excellences of the Prophet’s (peace be upon him) household. On the contrary,they have been advised here what they should do and what they should not, because Allah intendsto purify them. In other words, they have been told that if they adopted such and such anattitude and way of life, they will be blessed with cleanliness, otherwise not. However, if thewords “Allah intends to remove uncleanliness from you” are taken to mean that Allah has madethem infallible, then is no reason why all the Muslims who perform their ablutions beforeoffering the Prayer are not held as infallible, because about them also Allah says: “But Allahwills to purify you and complete His blessings upon you.” (Surah Al-Maidah, Ayat 6).
